Saturday, February 23, 2008

Separate but Equal?

BB NOTE: This looks to be a deliberate "leak" and we take that with a great deal of salt. In fact, if it was truly confidential we really wouldn't know about it - that it's being leaked with "no comment" from Rowan Williams' office is of note.

This is being spun that the TEC leaders will be in a tizzy over this, but it appears to be in fact the same proposal as the Primatial Scheme from Dar es Salaam, a jazzed up "Separate but Equal" proposal and we hope Rowan Williams knows how Americans feel about such schemes since 1954.

TEC is not going to allow competing franchises in The Episcopal Church that they cannot control, placing the unilateral brand at risk - and American Anglicans are not going to continue to be governed by the structures of The Episcopal Church that actively promotes heretical teaching. If these are bold steps toward creating parallel Anglican provinces with autonomous governing structures inside North America, that would be a bold plan indeed. We'd see it as a bold step towards peace. But let's see how this looks come Monday morning.

What this story really may be saying to us is that the Anglican Covenant is in danger.

From the London

Dr Rowan Williams has held confidential talks with senior American bishops and theologians who oppose the pro-gay policies of their liberal leaders.

A handful of hardline American dioceses are already defecting from the Episcopal Church, the American branch of Anglicanism, and transferring their loyalties to a conservative archbishop in South America.

Dr Williams is desperate to minimise further damage in the run up to the once-a-decade Lambeth Conference this summer which could be boycotted by more than a fifth of the world's bishops.

His recent comments backing aspects of sharia law have heightened tensions by further alienating Africans who are struggling with militant Islam in their dioceses.

According to insiders, Dr Williams has given his blessing to the plans to create an enclave for up to 20 conservative American bishops that would insulate them from their liberal colleagues.

The scheme would allow them to remain technically within the Episcopal Church but under the care of like-minded archbishops from abroad.

The Primate of the West Indies, Archbishop Drexel Gomez, a moderate conservative, has agreed to participate, and other primates could be recruited.

However, the initiative is likely to infuriate liberal leaders of the Episcopal Church, who will see it as an attempt to undermine their authority and interfere in their affairs.

Presiding Bishop Katherine Jefferts Schori, the head of the Episcopal Church, has been cracking down on any diocese or parish that seeks to leave, and numerous legal actions are under way.

She and her colleagues have already rejected similar proposals suggested at a meeting in Tanzania last year of all the primates, the leaders of the 38 independent Churches that constitute the Anglican Communion.

However, she met a group of conservative bishops and theologians in New York last week after hearing that Dr Williams was sympathetic to the new proposals.

Dr Williams, whose leadership has been under growing attack from conservatives, has been privately encouraging such a development for a number of years. So far, however, he has failed to broker a deal with Bishop Jefferts Schori, a feminist who backed the 2003 consecration of Gene Robinson as Anglicanism's first openly gay bishop.

With several hundred of the world's 880 bishops expected to boycott the Lambeth Conference in Canterbury, a schism is looking inevitable unless Dr Williams can paper over the cracks.

Lambeth Palace declined to comment.

Read the rest here.


Anonymous said...

There is lots to be skeptical about here. OTOH, it does match rather closely the sort of essential things which +Duncan lamented that +Cantuar had not done in the past. Why now, assuming there is any truth to it? (Note that +Iker has disavowed any knowledge of this!) Possibly a realization that the Anglican Communion is coming apart at the seams, and doing nothing is going to assure that. It is also going to insure a new resident in Lambeth Palace in the near future. So lets check back on Monday, which is about 72 hours later.

Anonymous said...

Sounds a lot like a trial balloon to me. Comment and analysis by skeptical bloggers should continue to show this for what it is - more lipstick for the pig.

Anonymous said...


for more details.
I think the pland is real, but don't know if it can be made to work or not.

Marie at Rez

Anonymous said...

Many of Petre's details were wrong, an Bp. John Howe has clarified it. It's real, but it's DOA.

Anonymous said...

Why is it DOA? Is not this what was mooted as acceptable once?

Unknown said...

I've offered a few thoughts in the post above that includes John Howe's letter.